Top SEO Agencies in New York City in 2024

Are you looking for Top SEO Agencies in New York City in 2024?, New York City is one of the most competitive markets for search engine optimization (SEO) with thousands of agencies promising to get your website to the top of Google. However, not all SEO agencies deliver on their claims.

With so many options to choose from, finding the right SEO company for your business can feel overwhelming. To help make your decision easier, we researched and compiled this list of the top-rated SEO agencies based in New York City as of 2024. These agencies have proven results in helping businesses improve organic rankings, traffic, and conversions.

How We Evaluated the Best SEO Agencies in NYC

We looked at over 150 SEO agencies in New York City and evaluated them on these criteria:

Aspect Description
SEO Success Stories and Client Results Highlighting successful projects and outcomes achieved for clients.
Google and Other Industry Certifications Demonstrating expertise through certifications from reputable sources.
Years of Experience in SEO Industry Showcasing extensive tenure and knowledge in the SEO field.
Strength of SEO Strategies and Expertise Detailing the effectiveness and depth of strategies employed, backed by expertise.
Customer Reviews and Testimonials Sharing feedback and satisfaction levels from previous clients.
Awards and Recognitions Received Illustrating acknowledgment and accolades for outstanding performance.
Reporting and Analytics Capabilities Emphasizing the ability to provide comprehensive data analysis and insights.
Size of Clientele and Monthly Retainers Indicating the scale of operations and commitment levels through client base and retainers.


Based on these factors, we selected top 10 SEO companies that delivered outstanding results for their reputed clients.

The Best SEO Agencies in New York City in 2024

1. WebFX

Overview: Award-winning agency offering SEO along with PPC, web design, & development services. 400+ successful SEO campaigns. Part of the Neil Patel Digital group of companies.

SEO Strategies: Technical audits, competitor research, content optimization, conversions tracking, link building

Results: Helped Casper Sleep rank #1 for “mattress” in Google with 780% increase in traffic. Increased LeadIQ’s leads by 222%.

Location: New York City

2. Conductor

Overview: Data-driven SEO agency focused on organic growth. Over 4,500 successful SEO campaigns globally.

SEO Strategies: Search intelligence diagnostics, content audits, technical SEO, outreach strategy

Results: 299% increase in traffic for Printique. Ranked #1 on Google for eyewear company Renouveau.

Location: New York City, 20+ global locations

3. WebiMax

Overview: Full-service digital marketing agency offering SEO, PPC, social media, web design and CRO. 1,500+ clients across 10 countries.

SEO Strategies: Local SEO, national SEO, international SEO, e-commerce SEO, enterprise SEO

Results: Increased CareDox’s leads by 333%. 30K new visitors per month for arts company ESKFF.

Location: New York City

4. Straight North

Overview: Boutique SEO agency focused on ROI. 90+ employees. Won Search Engine Land’s Best SEO Company 2021.

SEO Strategies: Site audits, keyword expansion, speed optimization, UI/UX refinement

Results: Generated $1 billion revenue for Revere Bank. Increased lead volume by 4X for AllenComm.

Location: New York City, Chicago, and other US locations

5. Blue Corona

Overview: Digital marketing agency offering SEO, paid social, CRO, web design,Amazon marketing, and analytics.

SEO Strategies: National and local SEO, e-commerce SEO, voice search optimization

Results: Generated 3X ROI for Humane Society. Increased impressions by 28% for TalkSpace.

Location: New York City

6. Main Path

Overview: Boutique performance marketing agency focused on measurable ROI for mid-market companies.

SEO Strategies: Tailored SEO strategy, on and off page optimization, conversions tracking

Results: 1600% increase in leads generated for Adicta Health. 528% more traffic for Rewire Security.

Location: New York City

7. Dezins Interactive

Overview: Offering SEO services along with PPC, web design, content writing and social media marketing. 100+ clients.

SEO Strategies: Local SEO, e-commerce SEO, vertical SEO, national SEO

Results: Higher SERP rankings for physio company BetterPT Health bringing 84% more website traffic.

Location: New York City


Overview: Full-service digital agency offering SEO, PPC, Amazon Marketing, web and app design services.

SEO Strategies: Competitor analysis, conversion rate optimization, technical website audits

Results: #1 Ranking on Google for high-end skincare company Krigler Switzerland

Location: New York City

9. Portent

Overview: Specialized internet marketing agency offering SEO consulting and content strategy services. Nomonthly contracts.

SEO Strategies: SEO auditing, keyword expansion, online reputation management

Results: Page 1 rankings for 9 out of 10 keywords for flight company JSX.

Location: Seattle, WA (servicing NYC remotely)

10. Bruce Clay Inc.

Overview: SEO focused digital marketing agency servicing enterprise level clients globally since 1996.

SEO Strategies: International and multilingual SEO, ecommerce SEO, local SEO

Results: 151% more site traffic for Pacific Life insurance generating $300k in sales. 300% increase in leads for Mercury Mosaics.

Location: Los Angeles, CA (servicing NYC remotely)

5 Factors to Consider When Hiring an NYC SEO Agency

Choosing an SEO company that fits your business’s specific needs is key to getting results. Here are the top 5 factors to evaluate:

1. Proven SEO Results

Look for quantifiable outcomes like increase in organic traffic, conversions, and revenue. Ask for client case studies.

2. Experience Optimizing Websites Like Yours

See if they have experience working with websites in your industry, location, and size.

3. Reporting and Analytics

Ensure they provide detailed analytics reporting to track SEO KPIs.

4. Characteristics That Allow for Scalability

If your business grows considerably, you want an agency equipped to scale with you.

5. Culture Fit

Make sure you vibe well with the team and feel confident in their expertise.

Invest in SEO to Grow Your Business in NYC

As one of the top media markets, New York City offers immense opportunities but also intense competition to rank well and acquire traffic. Investing in proven SEO agencies will give your website the visibility it needs to thrive.

We hope our curated list of the top SEO companies in NYC for 2024 will help guide your search to find the right partner dedicated to your SEO success. Let us know in the comments if you have any favorites that we missed.

Leave a Comment